Politics

Election Commission Has Not Produced Post-5 pm CCTV Footage From Maharashtra or Andhra Pradesh. It Has Moved to Delete Such Records After 45 Days

The Commission's May 2025 instruction to delete election CCTV and web-casting records after 45 days comes while questions over late polling in two states remain unanswered.


In May 2025, the Election Commission wrote to state election officers asking them to delete election CCTV, video records and web-casting footage if no court complaint is filed within 45 days. The instruction came while the Commission had still not produced footage to answer questions about late polling in Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh.

In Maharashtra, 76 lakh voters cast their votes after 5 pm across 114 assembly seats. The record cited for such voters is 50 lakh, not 25 lakh. No record shows how many voters were standing in queues at 5 pm in those 114 constituencies.

In Andhra Pradesh, polling continued until 2 am. The Commission has not shown CCTV footage to establish that the queues existed. No response from the Commission to either question is on record.

A 45-day deletion rule leaves the public with no footage to test the polling-hour numbers.

The rule followed a court order. In December 2024, the Punjab and Haryana High Court ordered that CCTV footage be given to Mehmood Pracha. It has been alleged that the Union government then changed the rules within 10 days so that CCTV and other election documents would not be handed out. The Commission's reason for the deletion instruction, as cited in its letter, was that people who are not contesting elections use such footage on social media to build a false narrative.

The alleged storage argument is not technical. Digital data can be held on a single drive for decades. The Commission has not explained why footage and voter lists must be destroyed after 45 days.

Footage that could settle the 5 pm question exists only until the 45-day clock runs out.

The Commission's leadership has also stayed out of public view, opposition critics allege. Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, Vivek Joshi and SS Sandhu have held no press conference for 2 months. The Commission's X handle has not carried a photo of Gyanesh Kumar since 26 September. The Commission has communicated through press releases and affidavits.

The allegations about voter roll deletions add to the pressure. Former Supreme Court judge Gopal Gowda has said that cutting 13 crore names through the Special Intensive Revision attacked the country's sovereignty. It has also been alleged that 27 lakh people in West Bengal were prevented from voting, even with 2.5 lakh paramilitary personnel deployed.

Home Minister Amit Shah has said there are 3 crore infiltrators and that the revision is meant to remove them. No figure of that scale has been published from the exercise.

The BJP says its wins rest on its workers, not on vote theft. The party has not asked the Commission to release the 5 pm CCTV footage from Maharashtra, Haryana, Odisha and Andhra Pradesh. Such footage from even 100 booths could answer the charge. No response from the BJP on this is on record.

A party confident of its mandate would ask for the footage. A regulator confident of its count would release it.

The footage either shows the queues or it does not. If the 45-day rule stands, who will ever know?

Sources

Sources: Election Commission of India letter to state election officers, May 2025; Punjab and Haryana High Court order, December 2024; Election Commission records on polling in Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh.

— End of Article —